| Number | Begin | End | Name |
| 40 | December 2024 | | Kevin J. Diehl |
| 39 | June 2023 | December 2024 | Joe Alfonso |
| 38 | May 2022 | June 2023 | Andrew Romano |
| 37 | May 2021 | May 2022 | Sean M. Dwyer |
| 36 | April 2020 | May 2021 | Gabe A. Diaz |
| 35 | May 2019 | April 2020 | Jeff Belfort |
| 34 | May 2018 | May 2019 | Spencer L. Scott |
| 33 | February 2018 | May 2018 | David J. Marranzini |
| 32 | January 2018 | May 2018 | David J. Marranzini |
| 31 | May 2017 | February 2018 | Mike T. Buckley |
| 30 | April 2016 | May 2017 | Joshua N. Pinnock |
| 29 | May 2015 | April 2016 | Edwin Barrios |
| 28 | May 2014 | May 2015 | Mr. Jonathan Rivera |
| 27 | May 2013 | May 2014 | Aldo Nolasco |
| 26 | March 2012 | May 2013 | Stephen Tolud |
| 25 | February 2011 | March 2012 | Kamau Cooper |
| 24 | October 2010 | February 2011 | Christoph M. Shamoun |
| 23 | May 2009 | October 2010 | Nathaniel Agosto |
| 22 | May 2008 | May 2009 | Rolando Nieves |
| 21 | May 2006 | May 2008 | Ryan Liatsis |
| 20 | June 2005 | May 2006 | Leonid Likhtenshteyn |
| 19 | April 2004 | June 2005 | Patrick Mora |
| 18 | October 2003 | March 2004 | Anthony Scavetta |
| 17 | October 2001 | October 2003 | Gary R. Marks Jr. |
| 16 | March 2001 | May 2001 | Mayor Andrew C. Wardell |
| 15 | May 2000 | February 2001 | Mayor Andrew C. Wardell |
| 14 | June 1999 | May 2000 | Matthew C Sinisi |
| 13 | June 1998 | June 1999 | Richard A Mortellaro |
| 12 | February 1998 | June 1998 | James R LoBue, Jr. |
| 11 | May 1997 | February 1998 | D. Scott Wilson |
| 10 | July 1996 | May 1997 | Mr. Christopher P. Merkel |
| 9 | June 1995 | July 1996 | Christopher S Krawtschuk |
| 8 | May 1994 | June 1995 | Paul Rodrigo |
| 7 | May 1993 | April 1994 | Nicholas Ferriero |
| 6 | December 1991 | | Andrew Diamond |
| 5 | January 1982 | December 1982 | Robert J. Zampese |
| 4 | January 1975 | December 1976 | Tony Cavotto |
| 1 | | | Victor Miranda Jr. |
| 2 | | | Bob J. Dowd |
| 3 | | | Dave Celeste |